2 p.m. A Makeover Story – Valentine Proposal John Paul and Libby were living the wild life and had no interest in getting involved in a serious relationship. That all changed when they met each other at a local bar, and friendship quickly turned to love. Now these party people are ready to settle down and give up the carefree single life as well as their style-free wardrobes. J.P. picked the most romantic night of the year, Valentine's Day, to ask Libby if she will do him the honor of becoming his wife.