Senior Member
Registered: 07-27-08
|
Personally, I have yet to be convinced of a guaranteed "easy" and "clean" method of execution.
The electric chair frequently works on the first try, but electrocutions have been botched, sometimes with horrific results. One case had a misinstalled portable chair result in the condemned lying on the floor screaming for some time until they could remount the chair.
Nooses can take off the head, or result in slow strangulation.
Firing squads have been known to miss the heart, causing slower, painful death. Hence the "coup de grace" head shot, which even a very, very few have survived.
Gas chambers are subject to debate because it's possible the person suffers suffocation, or acid build up in the lungs long enough to feel pain.
Lethal injection is also debated by some. Many murderers were intravenous drug users, and starting an IV is difficult and painful for them. There is a procedure called "cut down"; I'll leave you to google it. Let's just say that it's not pleasant. Even the drugs used may be problematic, and there are some authorities who claim that the person may be conscious when their lungs are paralyzed, so a painful suffocation results.
The guillotine seems to be the best choice, as it supposedly results in instant blood pressure loss and therefore unconsciousness. Again, there were some experiments (poorly documented) that may indicate some awareness survives beheading (personally, I doubt it).
Perhaps the best way would be oral drug overdose as done for some euthanasia patients in Europe. Massive amounts of opiates would appear to be relatively painless, but I seem to recall some accounts of seizures resulting. The state also has a problem with forcing people to ingest them, apparently. Force feeding someone poison would not be kind, either.
I've also heard that nitrogen poisoning is painless and quick. Just fill the chamber with nitrogen, and that's it.
NOTE: Some argue that whatever pain the condemned suffers they deserve, as it is frequently less than their victim. That is entirely beside the point, especially in the case of the wrongly convicted. If you claim to be carrying out an execution in a humane manner, then it is up to you to prove that.
|